The Night Sofia Said Nothing

Chapter 06 - The Night Sofia Said Nothing

They watched the video in a conference room with no windows.

Arthur Vale sat in a leather chair, older and thinner than Elena remembered him. The timestamp showed the recording had been made twenty-two months before his death.

Marcus’s voice came from behind the camera.

“Say it again.”

Arthur looked exhausted.

“I changed Miguel’s medication.”

Elena felt her mother beside her go rigid.

On the screen, Marcus asked, “Why?”

Arthur covered his face.

“Because Enzo told me to.”

“That is not a reason.”

“He had your sister followed. He had Caroline’s medical records. He had everything.”

Marcus’s voice shook.

“And Sofia?”

Arthur looked up.

Elena stopped breathing.

“She saw me.”

The video paused.

Not because anyone touched the computer.

Because Vivien had closed the laptop.

Elena turned.

“Open it.”

Vivien looked at Sofia.

“I think she should tell you herself.”

“No.”

Elena’s voice was quiet.

“Open it.”

Vivien obeyed.

Arthur continued.

“Sofia came into Miguel’s office after I switched the bottles. She saw me holding the pills.”

Marcus said something too low to hear.

Arthur shook his head.

“No. She didn’t help me.”

Elena’s fingernails dug into her palm.

“What did she do?”

Arthur looked straight into the camera.

“She begged me to change them back.”

Sofia began to cry.

Arthur continued.

“I told her Enzo had someone outside Elena’s school.”

Elena turned toward her mother.

Sofia stared at the screen.

“He showed me a photograph,” she whispered. “You were getting into Mrs. Delgado’s car after volleyball practice.”

Elena remembered Mrs. Delgado.

Her teammate’s mother.

A red minivan.

A life so ordinary it made the memory cruel.

On screen, Marcus asked, “So Sofia let Miguel take the pills?”

Arthur’s eyes filled.

“No.”

The room seemed to stop.

Elena looked back.

Arthur swallowed.

“She replaced them herself.”

Elena felt dizzy.

Sofia made a broken sound.

Arthur leaned toward the camera.

“She replaced the bottle with Miguel’s real medicine. I thought she’d ruined everything.”

Marcus said, “Then how did he die?”

Arthur closed his eyes.

“Enzo had a second man.”

Dante’s expression turned to stone.

Arthur’s voice grew faint.

“Miguel had coffee every afternoon from the machine in the accounting hall. They put something in the cup.”

Elena sat down.

For fourteen years she had imagined a pill bottle.

Now there was coffee.

An ordinary paper cup.

The same kind Miguel carried home sometimes because he hated wasting anything.

Arthur continued.

“Sofia called me that night. She said Miguel was dead. I told her she had to keep quiet or Elena would be next.”

Marcus asked, “Did you threaten her?”

“Yes.”

“Did you ever tell her Enzo was responsible for the second plan?”

“No.”

Arthur looked toward the floor.

“I let her believe she failed to save him.”

Sofia covered her face.

Elena turned off the video.

Silence.

Dante stood near the wall with both hands in his pockets.

Vivien sat in the far corner, still wearing the ruined wedding dress.

Elena looked at her mother.

“You tried to save him.”

Sofia did not lift her head.

“I did not save him.”

“That is not what I said.”

“I saw Arthur with the bottle. I knew something terrible was happening. I should have taken you and your father and run.”

“Where?”

“I don’t know.”

“Exactly.”

Sofia lowered her hands.

“I was afraid.”

Elena’s anger softened, but did not disappear.

Fear explained choices.

It did not erase their consequences.

“Why didn’t you tell me after Enzo disappeared?”

“Because he never disappeared to me.”

Elena frowned.

Sofia reached into her handbag and removed a stack of old envelopes held together with a rubber band.

No return addresses.

All addressed to Sofia.

One every year.

Elena opened the top envelope.

Inside was a photograph of her leaving work six years ago.

Another showed her walking beside Marcus.

Another, older, showed Elena at college.

On the back of each was a date.

Nothing else.

“He wanted me to know he could still see you,” Sofia said.

Dante’s eyes darkened.

“Why didn’t you bring these to police?”

“Which police?”

The question silenced him.

Sofia looked at Elena.

“I thought if I kept the shares quiet and you lived an ordinary life, eventually he would forget.”

“But then I started working at the Vale Foundation.”

“Yes.”

“Where Arthur was.”

“Yes.”

“Why didn’t you stop me?”

“I tried.”

Elena remembered.

Her mother had hated the job from the beginning.

She called Arthur “a man who smiles before he lies.”

Elena had thought it was class resentment.

“You could have told me why.”

“I could have.”

Sofia did not defend herself.

“I should have.”

Elena looked away.

There was something exhausting about learning that almost every warning from childhood had contained a secret adult meaning.

Vivien spoke from the corner.

“Daniel knew about the shares before I did.”

Elena turned.

“How?”

“Arthur told him.”

“Why would Arthur tell your brother?”

“Because Arthur owed Daniel money.”

Dante’s gaze sharpened.

“Gambling?”

Vivien nodded.

“Private games. Very large ones.”

Elena looked at the beautiful young bride who had destroyed her reputation.

“Why did you help Daniel frame me?”

Vivien’s eyes lowered.

“Because he told me if I didn’t, he would give Enzo your mother’s address.”

Sofia closed her eyes.

Elena felt anger rise again.

“You could have warned me.”

“Yes.”

“You could have gone to police.”

“Yes.”

“You could have refused.”

“Yes.”

Vivien looked up.

“I was a coward.”

No excuse.

Elena almost preferred one.

Vivien continued.

“And because I hated you.”

That surprised everyone.

Elena stared.

“Why?”

“Because Marcus loved you.”

“Then why marry him?”

Vivien laughed bitterly.

“Because I spent years wanting something that stopped being worth having the moment I got it.”

There was something painfully adult about the sentence.

Elena said nothing.

Vivien rubbed at the diamond ring Marcus had placed on her finger hours earlier.

“He agreed to marry me because Daniel controlled his mother’s treatment payments. I agreed because I thought I could eventually make him love me.”

“And the invitation?”

“Daniel sent it. He wanted Dante to appear publicly connected to you.”

Dante crossed his arms.

“Why?”

Vivien looked at him.

“To force Enzo out.”

“That makes no sense.”

“It does if Daniel wants Enzo dead.”

The room shifted.

Dante stepped forward.

“Your brother works for my uncle.”

“No.”

Vivien shook her head.

“He has been stealing from him for three years.”

Elena frowned.

“So Daniel is afraid of Enzo.”

“And wants him exposed.”

“Yes.”

“Then why kidnap Marcus?”

Vivien’s face collapsed.

“Because Marcus has the one thing that can send them both to prison.”

“What?”

“A recording.”

“Another one?”

Vivien nodded.

“Arthur recorded Enzo ordering Miguel’s death. The original recording.”

Dante stared.

“The cassette in the bank?”

“A copy.”

Elena felt cold.

“Where is the original?”

Vivien looked down at her phone.

A new message had appeared.

She showed them.

A photograph of Marcus tied to a chair.

Beneath it:

BRING SOFIA REYES AND THE SHARE CERTIFICATES.

Vivien’s hand shook.

“They don’t just want the recording anymore.”

Elena read the final line.

NO POLICE. NO SALVATORE.

She looked toward Dante.

He looked back.

May you like

THE MAFIA BOSS WAS TOASTING CHAMPAGNE WITH HIS MISTRESS... UNTIL HE FOUN...

t

THE MAFIA BOSS WATCHED HIS MAID STRUGGLE WITH A HEAVY MIRROR... UNTIL HI...

t

THE MAFIA BOSS WAS ABOUT TO BLAME AN INNOCENT MAN... UNTIL HIS MAID SPOK...

t

And Sofia said the sentence nobody in the room wanted to hear.

“I know where the original share certificates are.”