The Woman in Red Answered Too Soon

Chapter 02 - The Woman in Red Answered Too Soon
Nobody at that table lifted a fork.
White roses leaned over crystal bowls. Candle flames trembled along the polished surface of the long dining table. Somewhere near the kitchen doors, a young waiter forgot to breathe with his mouth closed.
Vanessa recovered first.
Women like her always did.
âLuca,â she said, soft enough to be intimate and loud enough to be heard, âyou cannot seriously believe a maidâs confused story over mine.â
It was not the word maid that hurt. I had been called that all night.
It was the way she used it, as though it named a lesser species.
Luca did not look at me. He watched Vanessa.
âI asked Olivia what happened,â he said.
âAnd I am telling you she fell.â
âNo.â His voice remained low. âYou told me before she could.â
A murmur passed among the guests like silk being torn.
Vanessaâs chin lifted. âBecause I saw it happen.â
My heart went cold.
She was very good.
She did not deny being in the cellar. She did not deny knowing about the injury. She made herself the witness before anyone asked for one.
Lucaâs eyes shifted to me. âDid Miss Bellini see it happen?â
I heard my fatherâs voice then, not from the room but from a hospital bed six miles away.
Liv, you tell the truth only to people strong enough to survive it.
The problem was I no longer knew if I was strong enough.
âI saw her,â I said carefully.
Vanessa exhaled with theatrical patience. âThere.â
I swallowed. âAfter.â
Her face changed.
Not much.
Enough.
Luca caught it too.
He turned to the guests. âDinner is delayed.â
One sentence emptied the room of oxygen.
His uncle, two cousins, a judgeâs widow, a real-estate partner from Miami, and a priest who had the misfortune of blessing the engagement toast all stared at him.
Vanessa stepped closer. âLuca, donât be ridiculous. We have people here.â
âYes,â he said. âThat is why I am being polite.â
He lifted one hand. A man in a dark suit appeared near the archway, as if the wall had produced him.
âEnzo,â Luca said. âNo one leaves the estate yet. Tell the kitchen to serve coffee in the east parlor.â
Vanessa laughed once. âYouâre trapping your own guests because a servant bumped her arm?â
Luca finally looked fully at her.
âIf this is nothing,â he said, âcoffee will not harm them.â
I should have felt relieved.
Instead, I felt like a match had been struck inside a sealed room.
Enzo moved quickly, quietly, with the blank face of a man who knew where every exit led. Guests rose in clusters. Chairs scraped. No one complained directly to Luca. They simply obeyed the atmosphere he created.
Within minutes, the grand dining room belonged to five people: Luca, Vanessa, Enzo, me, and the silver champagne bucket sitting on the table like evidence.
âOlivia,â Luca said, âtell me what happened in the cellar.â
My hands twisted together.
Vanessa stood across from me, red satin falling perfectly around her. She looked less frightened now. That worried me more.
âI went down for the Krug,â I said. âMrs. Dellucci asked for the older bottles to be chilled before dessert.â
âWho sent you?â Luca asked.
âThe kitchen steward.â
Enzo wrote nothing down. He only listened.
âAnd then?â
I looked toward the doorway. The room seemed too large for my voice.
âI heard someone behind the Merlot racks.â
Vanessa rolled her eyes. âThis is absurd.â
Luca did not turn. âSpeak again before she finishes and you can join the others.â
Her mouth closed.
I almost admired him for it.
Almost.
âSomeone was opening the old storage wall,â I said.
Lucaâs stillness sharpened. âWhich wall?â
âThe one behind the iron gate.â
Enzoâs eyes moved, just once, toward Luca.
Vanessa noticed.
So did I.
âThere is no storage wall there,â she said.
I stared at her.
It was the wrong sentence. Too quick. Too sure.
Luca folded his hands in front of him. âHow would you know?â
Vanessaâs lips parted.
No answer came.
âI clean,â I said quietly. âI know every wall that does not sound like a wall.â
For the first time, Luca looked at me not as a maid, not as a witness, but as a woman whose invisibility had made her dangerous.
âWhat did you see?â
âA black folder. A brass lockbox. And Miss Bellini with a man.â
Vanessaâs face went pale beneath her makeup.
Luca did not blink.
âWhat man?â
âI didnât see his face.â
That was true.
At least, it was true enough.
âHe had a ring,â I added. âOn his right hand. Gold. Square. With a blue stone.â
Enzo went rigid.
Luca turned to him. âYou know it?â
Enzo hesitated one beat too long.
âA few men wear rings like that,â he said.
âNo,â Luca replied. âNot in my cellar.â
Vanessa laughed again, but this time it broke in the middle. âDo you hear yourself? Youâre interrogating me during our engagement dinner because this girl invented a ghost with jewelry.â
I wanted to disappear.
Then Lucaâs gaze returned to my cheek.
âMove your hair,â he said.
I froze.
Vanessa whispered, âDonât.â
That was the second mistake she made.
Luca heard it.
I moved the loose strands away from the right side of my face.
The bruise showed in the chandelier light, imperfectly hidden by powder. Not huge. Not theatrical. Just enough for every lie in the room to become uglier.
Lucaâs expression did not soften.
It closed.
âWhat were they doing with the folder?â he asked.
âI donât know.â
âOlivia.â
My voice became smaller. âI saw one word before she grabbed me.â
No one moved.
âWhat word?â
I looked at Vanessa.
Then at Luca.
âLucia,â I said.
The name changed him.
It did not frighten him.
It wounded him.
For one small unguarded moment, Luca Moretti looked less like a man who controlled a city and more like a son hearing his dead mother called from another room.
âMy motherâs name,â he said.
Vanessa said, âCoincidence.â
But Luca was not listening to her anymore.
He looked down at the silver bucket, then at the closed doors of the dining room, then back at me.
May you like
âShow me the cellar,â he said.
And behind him, Vanessa slowly reached for her evening clutch as if someone inside it might save her.