What Elena Tried to Say
Chapter 08 - What Elena Tried to Say
Rose had been fourteen on the afternoon Elena died. She remembered the waiting room at Brennan's private clinic, the sour smell of coffee, a watercolor of boats above a magazine rack. Elena had asked Miriam to bring Rose for one last conversation because she said she had finally obtained documents proving where Rose had been taken after birth.
“Mother was crying when we arrived,” Rose told Ortiz. “But not the way people cry when they're sick. She was angry. She had a manila folder on her lap. She said, ‘I have the names.’ Then Brennan came in and told us to wait outside.”
Ten minutes later a nurse emerged. Elena had suffered a fatal reaction to medication, the nurse said. She had not regained consciousness. Miriam argued so fiercely that security escorted her and Rose from the building. They were never given the folder.
“Why didn't you tell anyone?” Ortiz asked.
“I told everybody. I was fourteen. They called it shock.”
An exhumation was legally possible, Ortiz explained, but complex after so many years. More promising was the clinic's preserved pharmacy inventory, if it still existed. She instructed Gideon not to touch the safe until investigators could witness the opening. He agreed, though it cost him to let strangers walk into the study where his father once conducted business.
The safe stood behind a small painting of the Hudson River. Gideon typed the code Celeste had supplied. The lock clicked on the second attempt. Inside were family bonds, passports, and a packet of old receipts, all familiar to him. Beneath a false bottom Ortiz found a narrow metal case marked with Elena's initials.
There were photographs, a diary, and a small digital recorder whose battery had swollen with age. A technician copied the files without connecting the device to a network. Later, in a conference room with Rose beside him, Gideon heard Elena's voice for the first time in fifteen years.
“I am recording this because Martin tells me no one will believe me,” Elena said. “My daughter was born alive. I signed no surrender. Father says the family must avoid another scandal. I don't know what he's offered them. I only know the little girl they say died was in my arms for twenty-three minutes.”
There was a long silence on the recording. Then Elena whispered, “Gideon, if you hear this, I tried to tell you. I was afraid of what he'd do to Miriam. I don't blame you for being away. I blame you for never calling back.”
Gideon bent forward, his face hidden in his hands. Rose reached toward him, stopped, then placed one hand on his shoulder. That small choice seemed to require all her courage.
Further recordings described Elena's growing suspicion that the clinic had been arranging falsified adoptions for years. She had collected names from women she'd met in a grief-support group. Some mothers believed their infants were dead. Others had been pressured to sign documents while sedated. Elena intended to speak with a prosecutor outside the family's influence.
The final file ended abruptly. Elena said, “If Martin comes back before I can leave, tell Miriam the blue folder is—” A door opened. The rest was the shuffle of clothing and a man's voice ordering her to put the recorder away.
Ortiz sent the audio for forensic analysis. Gideon went home without speaking to anyone. Mallerie found him the next day in the mansion conservatory, standing before a dead fern he had been watering for weeks.
“You can't bring Elena back,” she said.
“I know.”
“You can help Rose.”
“I know that too.”
He rubbed his palms together. “You think I'm a monster.”
“No. Sometimes that would be easier. I think you were a powerful man who learned not to look closely at the suffering that made his life comfortable.”
He accepted the sentence in silence. “I am trying to change that.”
“Then do it when no one is watching.”
Over the following week Gideon did something the city's newspapers found less interesting than his engagement scandal. He opened the foundation's records to investigators, resigned as its chair pending review, and set aside private funds for independent legal assistance to families identified in the hospital inquiry. Denise insisted the money be administered without Gideon's influence. He agreed.
Rose began helping Ortiz locate the women named in Elena's recordings. Not every story ended in a reunion. One woman had died. Another refused to reopen old wounds. Rose learned to respect those answers, too. She was no longer merely looking for herself; she was beginning to understand what her mother had tried to finish.
Mallerie had her first unsupervised afternoon with Owen at Janet's home. He crawled under the kitchen table, threw his cracker to the dog, and stood for three seconds with both hands pressed against her knees. It was an ordinary miracle, which meant it would never appear in an official report.
That night Ortiz telephoned. Brennan had been brought in for questioning, but his attorney secured his release. Before leaving, the doctor had made one statement about Elena's death.
“He says Gideon was present when Elena received the fatal injection,” Ortiz said.
May you like
Mallerie thought of the recording, the brother who had been away, the story he'd told about returning too late.
“And he says Gideon has lied about that afternoon for fifteen years.”
